A co-worker lent me a book that she thought I would like called "The Perfect Manhattan." It's about a girl who graduates college and decides to bartend in NYC while waiting for her writing career to take off. "I know you don't like chick lit," she said "But you'll like this."
I hate chick lit. I hate the pink flowy poorly written books that focus on relationships and fashion as the center of the universe. I tried to read a chick lit book in college called Mr. Maybe. A friend lent it to me, saying it would "speak to me." It did speak to me - in a grating, high-register, sorority voice that said "like" and "omigod" every other word. I couldn't even get past chapter one.
For some reason, this kind of drivel pisses me off to a nearly irrational level. Is there a market for this kind of thing? Most of the women I know are intelligent and enjoy books with actual plots and craft. Who is buying these crap fests?
Here's an example of a passage from this latest Estrogen Stereotyping Du Jour:
"'Love your lip gloss, cutie pie...It's Nars Baby Doll, isn't it?'...'And your bronzer!' the other man exclaimed, bubbling with excitement. 'Don't tell me - Laura Mercier! I love her products. You know what they say, bronzer's all fun and games until you look like you've been hit in the head with a pumpkin!'"
Has anyone ever had a conversation like this? Ever? And with a guy? I never have and I have a fair amount of gay friends.
Or try this:
"The other line looked like the typical Spark clientele: girls in Jimmy Choo stilettos, short Chip and Pepper skirts, and brightly colored Dior tanks, guys in the standard male uniform of Hickey Freeman or Ascot Chang button-downs rolled 'casually' to the sleeves, and Cole Haan or Gucci loafers."
What? Who gives a shit? And this isn't an anomaly. In the first 10 pages, she drops the brand name of clothes or shoes 4 times. Think about that. I don't care that your shoes are Dolce and Gabbana and that your jeans are Citizens for Humanity. What type of audience does? Does this mean something to someone?
Let's not even get into the ridiculous proposition that a girl who bartends out of college can afford designer clothes, an apartment in the West Village, and yoga classes. Where is *this* Manhattan? I want to live there.
As far as I can tell, the plot is about working at a bar and then working for a summer in the Hamptons. And there are boys or something. The authors (yes, plural. It took more than one person to create a pile of shit this deep) were bartenders at a Manhattan bar called Oneils - which is obviously the bar they are basing their fictional "Finton's" joint on (they even give the same address and interior details) - and at a place in the Hamptons. Whoa! What range! But it's not autobiographical. Oh no. I'm sure the hair products are different.
I just cannot fathom that someone would write this crap, get it published, and get read by anyone. But someone must be buying these books. And as long as people pay for it, then publishers will continue to think that this is the shit that all women care about.